
Rinehart footed with royalty bill in billion-dollar dispute
Hancock Prospecting (HPPL) will have to pay royalties from Hope Downs to one of its biggest rivals after the WA Supreme Court upheld Wright Prospecting’s claim involving legacy deeds signed by Gina Rinehart’s father. The decades-long legal battle has culminated in a ruling from Justice Jennifer Smith, who found HPPL is the beneficial owner of the Hope Downs share but upheld Wright Prospecting’s claim to royalties.The proceedings were concerned with formal agreements made decades ago between Lang Hancock, Peter Wright and Don Rhodes. A major consideration was who held the beneficial ownership of the Hope Downs and East Angelas exploration licenses when they were acquired in 1988 and 1989, and who now holds the beneficial interest in the 50% share of the Hope Downs mining lease. Following the ruling, Hancock Prospecting framed the central issue as ownership of the Hope Downs and East Angelas tenements, rather than “the far less significant issue of royalties”. “HPPL welcomes the WA Supreme Court decision which decisively confirms HPPL’s rightful ownership of these tenements firmly rejecting the baseless ownership claims of John, Bianca and Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (WPPL) in their entirety,” executive director Jay Newby said in a statement. Hope Downs today generates hundreds of millions of dollars in taxes and royalties for the WA Government. “The remaining Rhodes royalty claim historically attributable to HPPL amounts to approximately $4m per annum for Rhodes and for WPPL approximately $14m per annum,” Mr Newby said. Hancock does not expect to shoulder that burden alone. Mr Newby said any amounts payable in royalties and interest are a shared responsibilities with Rio Tinto (ASX: RIO), its partner in Hope Downs. “ a further royalty contribution in this regard, which will lessen contribution,” he said. “We will consult with our partner and consider our position on these matters.” Counsel on both sides will have 21 days to lodge their appeals.
















